Three concurrent music reality shows happened in India - Zee TV’s Sa Re Ga Ma Pa, Star Plus’ Voice of India and Sony’s Indian Idol. All were designed to discover singing talents through public voting. There are a few salient features of these shows: a) Some real talent and extremely good singing comes to the forefront b) Big names in the music industry come as judges and show people that they can quarrell too c) People can vote any number of times paying a premium on the telephone calls/SMS d) Voting is not based on singing capabilities alone but who people can identity with e) A combination of community pride and unlimited voting ensures that the organizers smile their way to the bank f) Girls almost never made it to the very top People feel a personal sense of involvement in these shows, as they play ‘king-makers’. In India, a country of diverse communities - these shows have contributed to accentuation of regional and community pride and a chance to make the local boy or girl a part of the national mainstream. Indian Idol was won by Prashant Tamang - who managed to unite all Nepali-speaking people from parts of India, Nepal and overseas into voting for him and feeling a shared joy of ethnic pride. Sony’s Voice of India contest is still continuing. In my view, some of the contestants of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa are way above competition. They are trained, seasoned singers with an ability to mesmerize. My favourite in the show was Raja Hasan of India, followed by Amanat Ali of Pakistan. Raja’s performances such as Piya Haji Ali, Vande Maatram, Allah Ke Bande , Padharo Mahre Desh, Omkara and Naina Thag Lenge left me spellbound. Some of the memorable performances by Amanat were Tujhse naaraaz nahin zindagi, Ye housla kaise jhuke, Mitwa, Albela Sajan, Tori Lachke and Hungama Hai Kyon Barpa. In the finals on October 13, votes got divided into India and Overseas. In the Indian voting, Raja stood 1st, while Amanat 3rd - Aneek Dhar of India stood 2nd. In the overseas voting , Amanat stood 1st while Raja 3rd, with Aneek 2nd. Because the votes of Raja and Amanat getting divided, the ultimate winner was Aneek. Despite being a good singer, he had lost a lot of goodwill because of the excessive promotion by his mentor Himesh Reshammiya. In many ways, he won because of Himesh. In many ways, he won despite Himesh. Below are the tabulation of the votes.